jjhardy
Displaced Tuluki
Posts: 288
|
Post by jjhardy on Mar 26, 2014 14:35:37 GMT -5
I honestly think we should try to engage in an open discussion with ARM staff, but try to keep things civil and constructive. Perhaps a dialogue meant to bridge the gap. It might not change the status quo, but maybe it might help bridge the gap, perhaps we can steer the conversation to the following agenda:
1. Give old players a chance to come back 2. Offer another amnesty to give some players a new start 3. Agree to just take a look at things and pledge to give ideas a second thought. 4. Get them to have players do some designing and implement some ideas.
Things of that nature I believe can be achieved with some open dialogue. We might want to reach out to NYR first and work our way through the ranks.
Any positive and constructive ideas?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 26, 2014 14:46:41 GMT -5
There's absolutely no way you'll get a reasonable conversation with Nyr if you expect him to make any kind of concession whatsoever. He has shown time and time again that the merest hint of criticism or suggestion that everything isn't perfect brings out the hostile totalitarian ruler in him. I'd be glad to be proven wrong, but I have never witnessed him budge an inch when faced with anything short of praise. He is incapable of acknowledging that he could be responsible for something that is wrong, which is the main reason the game has become so shit. He's a quasi-narcissistic power junkie, you won't get an open dialogue.
It may be possible for people to get unbanned on the basis of his perception of them "coming crawling back," which he will use to claim that he was right but willing to allow them back in on his conditions, probably including relegation to second-rate players (no karma, no admin assistance, etc.) Any actual changes to the game are an exercise in futility as he would see it as an admission of imperfection on his part. He's not a person who will ever accept that he could be wrong about something significant, he will at best agree to a minor compromise on some pretense of grace. Such a compromise would not extend to changes to the game that he doesn't agree to and hasn't suggested himself. People can get unbanned if they grovel, that's as much as you'll get out of him.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 26, 2014 14:48:43 GMT -5
I frankly don't see it happening when even posting here gets you banned, and there is an overriding staff policy that they are there to more or less preserve the changelessness of the world at large. I wish anyone who tries this luck, and there's a reason I don't often come out and just rail against the ineffectualness of playing by their terms. Because when I do, it makes even my husband who is a 15 year arm veteran stop playing for months, or this most recent one might even be permanent, because there is so much I hold back on here, so much, in order to try and sound more fair and even handed and not extremely angry and beyond frustrated at seeing such a beautiful world driven into the ground by people who know they are doing this but, since they do not play any longer, don't even care.
|
|
|
Post by jcarter on Mar 26, 2014 14:52:01 GMT -5
jjhardyi'm not trying to flame you or punk you out but what's the deal man, one day you're talking about executing dictators and kicking out nyr and the next you want to sit down and write an internet treaty of versailles
|
|
jjhardy
Displaced Tuluki
Posts: 288
|
Post by jjhardy on Mar 26, 2014 15:12:17 GMT -5
jjhardyi'm not trying to flame you or punk you out but what's the deal man, one day you're talking about executing dictators and kicking out nyr and the next you want to sit down and write an internet treaty of versailles I just like starting conversations frankly, I don't necc. do everything that I am saying on here. I haven't sat down and played ARM in a bit and honestly, I am giving the new one a try. However, other persons are interested in something like this and I haven't seen this issue being addressed, sure we talk about it here, but we don't do anything about it. I tried to open this same conversation previously but I don't think it got anywhere, I am all about the dialogue and seeing how things can be changed. Besides which, getting rid of NYR and being realistic when it comes to working with the mud and understanding he is here to stay are two different animals. If he is permanent, and getting rid of him is not an option, If you can't beat em, join em right?
|
|
jjhardy
Displaced Tuluki
Posts: 288
|
Post by jjhardy on Mar 26, 2014 15:14:11 GMT -5
What if some well-meaning persons ask how much it would cost to purchase the rights to own ARM, do you think it would be worthwhile?
|
|
drunkendwarf
Displaced Tuluki
SUCK IT, NYR AND ADHIRA
Posts: 211
|
Post by drunkendwarf on Mar 26, 2014 15:30:12 GMT -5
Yeah. Based on the fact that they might ban you for even being here, the fact that not a whisper of this board is on the GDB and that not a single currently active staffer has openly arrived on this board to discuss anything, you're wasting your time.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 26, 2014 15:32:42 GMT -5
You can't buy Armageddonmud. The copyright license of the code forbids it. They don't own the codebase, so they aren't able to sell it to you.
|
|
drunkendwarf
Displaced Tuluki
SUCK IT, NYR AND ADHIRA
Posts: 211
|
Post by drunkendwarf on Mar 26, 2014 15:32:52 GMT -5
Also, some of us have revealed enough stuff in the spoilers forum, I highly doubt we'd ever be welcomed back.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 26, 2014 15:52:08 GMT -5
Besides which, getting rid of NYR and being realistic when it comes to working with the mud and understanding he is here to stay are two different animals. If he is permanent, and getting rid of him is not an option, If you can't beat em, join em right? I think part of the core backbone of why these boards are so populated and rather unique as situations with established RPIs go in that there are more members of this board than there are regular armageddon players is that many people are in agreement that there is something deeply flawed and deeply wrong with something they care, soul-deep, about, and that they are not willing to just let it go, and that many of them have had such horrible problems with nyr (or staff policies, or Adhira) that they are willing to risk losing that thing altogether (in some cases willingly giving that thing up) to act as a voice of dissent, and as such, without any actual and meaningful changes, esp demotion or firing of Nyr as one possible one, 'crawling back' or 'joining them' as you put them, is not worth it. Your last sentence presupposes there are only two options: beat them or join them. When there are a large quantity of people here who have opted for number three: walk the fuck away from the game itself because you can't beat them on your own but damned if you can tolerate joining them with the state that things are currently in.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 26, 2014 17:12:55 GMT -5
Now I'm writing this to those here that might be serious about this. Those who's posts I read, not so much the lurkers and not the staff lurkers (because they probably already understand this).
Does anyone remember when Nessalin used to be the big bad guy? Back then I bet people wish he'd get replaced.... I think he got replaced, to some degree anyway. There's a new bad guy on the block and Nessalin probably showed him the ropes before stepping out.
The chances of Nyr being replaced are much greater if there's someone there to replace him. So, speaking hypothetically, who wants to apply to be on staff, work for years and be that person, only to spend even more time dealing with asshole players, all while maintaining a smile and their own life? I don't think I want to do that. Consider that Nyr might be a nice guy in real life, but the game has turned him into a monster to deal with because he just doesn't care anymore and somethings go to give. Perhaps he'd like to step out too but there's no one willing/qualified.
How long did Sanvean and Nessalin hold the reins, how did they get replaced?
Personally at the moment I've got other concerns that I'm prioritizing over problems with Arm staff, but I thought I might try and offer some perspective.
|
|
jjhardy
Displaced Tuluki
Posts: 288
|
Post by jjhardy on Mar 26, 2014 17:16:47 GMT -5
Yeah. Based on the fact that they might ban you for even being here, the fact that not a whisper of this board is on the GDB and that not a single currently active staffer has openly arrived on this board to discuss anything, you're wasting your time. I got banned for mentioning this board on multiple discussions on the GDB. IIRC, I had a bunch of windows opened and posted and bobbed and weaved like old skool Tyson.
|
|
|
Post by yaznokumf on Mar 26, 2014 21:17:04 GMT -5
Armageddon Mud: Murder. Corruption. Betrayal. Forgiveness.
Hmm, doesn't sound plausible.
In my very limited experience with the Staff Sanvean was always reasonable and even handed. Raesanos seemed reasonable, but both of them are not actively involved anymore. While I would applaud the effort, I don't see it happening.
Starting a new account if you haven't played it a while, I don't see how they would track you down, other than realizing you are veteran player, I'm not sure how effective they would be at identifying you as a banned player, IP addresses and service providers change.
Granted you won't be able to play any Karma required roles, but mundane role would be available.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 26, 2014 22:46:43 GMT -5
Player and Staff conversations happen. I would say once every two years? Which is a pretty common thing. If I recall correctly, the last one was even held on Teamspeak, or some variation of it that I've forgotten. Nobody mentioned Nyr during that meeting. In fact, the whole meeting went relatively uneventful, mostly already known things rementioned and regurgitated. Direct Player and Staff conversations, in my opinion, do not work.
But this whole forum is one giant conversation with the Imms. They imms and the players read these forums. The popularity of these forums have increased to such a point that if I hear a player say he doesnt know about them, I will be completely and absolutely certain he's not only a lurker, but probably an active participant.
In other words, conversation is already open. We know what they say. They know what we say. It is in our power to decide how to play, or whether to play at all. It is in our power to decide how to speak or whether to speak at all. It is in their power to do ... everything else.
There is no need for direct real time conversation. Many of us dont even really know exactly what is it that we want from staff. I think in an another topic, I've asked for suggestions and different people posted points that were opposite of each other. Cant please everybody. And that's normal. The only "wrong" way that an objective person can be aware of is one that proved itself to not work for years and has an alternative that 'might' possibly work better.
There are people on these forums who will not accept "anything" except total concession. There are people on the staff who will not accept any conclusion except the one they participated in forming. That's alright. Let them form their own conclusions. I am pretty certain they will be forming them, keeping what they read on "these" forums in mind. For better, or worse.
And that type of conversation "does" work. It even works on GDB, if you recall a total outcry during the rape ruling. It made the Imms reevaluate and rewrite the rule. These forums just have an option of similar outcries across a whole series of topics and in ways that if done carefully, hold no negative or positive effects on player's accounts. Unlike GDB.
Any amnesty of people who were banned within the last two years will not work. What exactly will it achieve? Allow those players back in the game? Okey. They're back. They could've returned with a different IP, but no matter, they're back with their normal IPs. Now what? Their Karma is low, nobody trusts them. Nobody likes them.
Even if Imms are neutral towards them, the player will not be able to stop suspecting that anything bad happening to their characters was caused by a vangeful imm. Walked in on a spider roving band? Imms loaded them. Backstabbed a rinthi npc and had 6 other NPCs come out of hiding and assist? Imm animation. That Bahamet 2 leagues away walked right towards you, while you were resting at 0 stam? Imm moved it. Could be true, probably not. But there will always be suspicion.
Works other way as well. They'll be watched like hawks. Shit that other people, including imm and legend played do on a regular basis, is found too twinky. Even if there are no negative notes placed, the imms would talk and talk about twinkiness amidst each other, until they rile themselves negatively to a point where "nothing" you do, is considered good. Imms are people too. People are assholes.
Amnesty of +2 years is a little easier. Time cures all. And any butthurt Imm who thought ill of you during banning, probably switched to some other player to be butthurt about. But there was an amnesty less then two years ago already. So amnesty stuff is in my opinion, an empty gesture.
|
|
|
Post by legendary on Mar 26, 2014 23:54:00 GMT -5
I don't think any discussion will hold water.
These forums actively shares vast swathes of information about the game, breaking a cardinal rule. What valid arguments are made here will be dismissed because of it, just as has happened in the past when there were problems with the IRC channel. How many players were involved in sharing information, plotting off-game the assassination of characters such as Riandra, Ysania, Pearl and various others.
The channel provided a means of conversation amongst players and staff, even the infamous Nessilian was a member of the channel (and later impersonated). There was merit to it's existence, but with the sharing of information and the regular plotting made it a target of staff ire, particularly from Sanvean. The opinions of various members were never given weight in discussions and the characters of those players were placed under perpetual suspicion.
Players like Callisto, Carnage, Armaphreak (Spelling? It's been some time.) were all players involved in some shady goings on, but even when playing straight characters and behaving themselves, they were victimized. One instance comes to mind where Arma' assassinated a plot-centric noble, an Oash I believe, who wore a helmet of some power. He was immediately set upon by vengeful staff for the killing, even when he held legitimate in-game reasons for the act. Several other of his elven characters were treated to similar staff-directed executions for flimsy reasons at best.
Every known player on this forum will never receive a fair shake from the current Armageddon administration. All discussion here towards reconciliation and cooperation will be dismissed and labeled invalid because of the severe and on-going breech of decades old draconic rules. Period. Their game, their precious, precious rules. For some of them, even more precious than the game itself.
The barrage of personal (and some well-earned) attacks on the lead administrator alone will assure a continued effort towards "putting down" members of this "dissident" forum. You don't simply drop a turd in someone's corn flakes one sunny morning and expect them not to take it personally, do you?
The schism is far too deep, all this forum serves is a place for the rebellious and the banned to congregate and discuss the state of the game openly, for all to see.
If that is enough or not remains to be seen.
|
|